Security First Insurance Claims in Florida: When Your Payout Falls Short

Security First Insurance Denied or Underpaid Your Claim? You're Not Alone

You paid your premiums on time, filed your claim after the storm, and waited — only to receive a settlement offer that doesn't come close to covering the real cost of repairs. Or worse, a denial letter citing a policy exclusion you've never heard of. If you're a Security First Insurance policyholder in Florida, this experience is frustratingly common, and it has driven thousands of homeowners to seek legal help.

Security First Financial, a Florida domestic carrier headquartered in Ormond Beach, markets itself as a company built specifically for Florida homeowners. That pitch resonates in a state where most national carriers have retreated. But being a Florida-focused insurer doesn't automatically mean policyholders are treated fairly when disaster strikes. Across South Florida — including in Hollywood and Broward County, where storm exposure is high and repair costs are steep — Security First policyholders regularly report disputes over roof damage, water intrusion, and hurricane claims.

This article explains what rights you have, what tactics insurers use to limit payouts, and exactly how an experienced property damage attorney can help you fight back.

Common Reasons Security First Insurance Denies or Underpays Claims

Insurance companies are for-profit businesses. Every dollar they pay in claims is a dollar off their bottom line. Understanding the most common strategies Security First — and Florida insurers in general — use to minimize payouts puts you in a stronger position to challenge them.

Pre-Existing Damage or Wear and Tear Exclusions

One of the most frequently cited denial reasons is the claim that damage was caused by "wear and tear," "deferred maintenance," or "pre-existing conditions" rather than a covered peril like wind or water from a storm. Adjusters are trained to look for signs of aging shingles, old caulking, or prior storm scars. Even if a recent hurricane clearly worsened existing vulnerabilities and caused new structural damage, Security First may attempt to attribute the entire loss to pre-existing conditions — paying nothing or dramatically reducing the settlement.

Low Ball Estimates from Preferred Contractors and Adjusters

Security First, like most insurers, controls costs by relying on in-house adjusters or contractors from approved vendor lists whose estimates consistently run below market rates. In South Florida, where labor and materials are more expensive than inland areas, a carrier-provided estimate may cover only 60-70 cents on every dollar needed for a proper repair. The insurer frames this as a complete payment. It isn't.

Coverage Disputes Over Causation

When a property sustains both wind damage (typically covered) and flood damage (typically excluded without a separate flood policy), determining the dominant cause of loss becomes a legal battleground. Security First adjusters may attribute significant damage to flooding rather than wind-driven rain or roof failure — effectively shifting losses to an uncovered category. In hurricane-prone Broward County, this causation dispute is one of the most contentious issues policyholders face.

Late or Incomplete Documentation Used Against You

Florida policyholders must provide timely notice of claims and cooperate with investigations. If there are gaps in your documentation, delays in reporting, or inconsistencies between your public adjuster's estimate and the insurer's, Security First may use these administrative issues as grounds to limit or deny payment. Many homeowners don't realize the documentation burden they carry until it's too late.

Roof Claim Disputes Under HO Policies

Security First's homeowners policies — like many Florida domestic carriers post-reform — often contain provisions that limit roof coverage based on age, require "matching" determinations, or apply separate roof deductibles. Policyholders expecting full roof replacement after a covered event may receive only an actual cash value payment that accounts for depreciation, leaving a large uncovered balance.

Florida Laws That Protect You as a Security First Policyholder

Florida has a detailed statutory framework governing insurer conduct. These laws were updated significantly by Senate Bill 2A in 2023, and understanding the current landscape is essential before you take action.

Florida Statute 627.70131 — Claim Acknowledgment and Payment Deadlines

Under Florida law, your insurer must acknowledge your claim within 14 days of receiving notice and begin its investigation promptly. Once the investigation is complete — or within 90 days of receiving your proof of loss — Security First must either pay the claim, deny it in writing, or issue a partial payment with written explanation of why the remainder is being withheld. Missing these deadlines is not merely a procedural error; it can support a bad faith claim against the insurer.

Senate Bill 2A (2023) — What Changed and What It Means for You

Florida's 2023 insurance reform legislation, SB 2A, significantly altered the rules for policyholder litigation. The assignment of benefits (AOB) arrangement — where contractors could sue insurers on behalf of homeowners — was eliminated for new claims. The one-way attorney fee statute that once allowed policyholders to recover attorney fees from an insurer who underpaid was also restructured.

Under the new framework, fee awards are tied to how close the final settlement comes to the amount the policyholder demanded versus what the insurer offered. This means the gap between the insurer's initial offer and your actual recovery determines whether — and how much — attorney fees can be recovered. The reform makes it more important than ever to document your damages thoroughly from day one and to consult an attorney before accepting any settlement.

Florida Statute 624.155 — Civil Remedy for Bad Faith

If Security First fails to act in good faith — by conducting a biased investigation, ignoring material evidence, making unreasonable interpretations of your policy, or delaying payment without cause — you may have a bad faith claim under Florida Statute 624.155. Before filing a bad faith lawsuit, you must serve a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) on the insurer and the Florida Department of Financial Services, giving the insurer 60 days to "cure" the violation by paying the full amount owed. If the insurer fails to cure, you may pursue damages beyond the policy limits, including consequential damages and attorney fees.

This is a powerful lever that many policyholders don't know they have. An experienced attorney can evaluate whether your Security First claim rises to the level of bad faith and prepare the required CRN to preserve your rights.

Florida's Valued Policy Law

For total losses to your dwelling caused by a covered peril, Florida's Valued Policy Law requires the insurer to pay the full face value of the policy — regardless of the insurer's estimate of replacement cost. If Security First disputes the scope of the loss or claims only partial destruction, this statute may still apply depending on the extent of structural damage. An attorney can assess whether this protection applies to your situation.

Step-by-Step: What to Do If Security First Denies or Underpays Your Claim

A denial or low settlement offer is not the end of the road. Here is how to build the strongest possible case for recovery.

Step 1: Document Everything Before You Repair

Do not make permanent repairs until you have photographed and video recorded every inch of damage. Capture timestamps. Get written estimates from two or three independent licensed contractors — not just Security First's preferred vendor. Preserve damaged materials where you safely can. Once repairs are made, proving the original scope of loss becomes exponentially harder.

Step 2: Request the Complete Claim File

You are entitled to a copy of your complete claim file under Florida law, including the adjuster's notes, inspection reports, internal communications, and any reserve amounts set for your claim. Requesting this file early often reveals inconsistencies — adjusters who relied on outdated pricing, missed damage items noted in their own reports, or conclusions that contradict the physical evidence. This file becomes foundational evidence if you pursue appraisal or litigation.

Step 3: Hire a Licensed Public Adjuster or Attorney Before Accepting Any Settlement

If Security First has issued a low settlement offer, do not cash the check without understanding what rights you may be waiving. A public adjuster can conduct an independent damage assessment and prepare a competing estimate. An insurance claims attorney can review your policy, evaluate the insurer's coverage position, and advise you on whether appraisal, mediation, or litigation is the appropriate next step. These professionals work together to maximize your recovery — and typically work on contingency, meaning no upfront cost to you.

Step 4: Invoke the Appraisal Clause if There Is a Dispute Over the Amount

Most Security First homeowners policies include an appraisal clause. If you and the insurer agree that a loss is covered but disagree on how much it costs to repair, either party can invoke appraisal. Each side selects a licensed, competent appraiser, and those two appraisers select an umpire. The panel's decision on the amount of the loss is binding. Appraisal is faster and less expensive than litigation and can result in significantly higher settlements than the insurer's initial offer.

Step 5: File a Complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services

The Florida DFS Division of Consumer Services handles complaints against insurers. Filing a complaint creates a formal record of the dispute, may trigger an investigation, and sometimes prompts the insurer to reconsider its position. It also establishes a paper trail that supports a bad faith claim if litigation becomes necessary.

Step 6: Consult an Insurance Claims Attorney

If appraisal and negotiation fail — or if Security First is engaging in delay tactics, requesting unnecessary documentation, or denying coverage without a credible legal basis — it is time to retain legal counsel. An attorney can file a Civil Remedy Notice for bad faith, pursue litigation in circuit court, and handle all communications with the insurer so you can focus on rebuilding your life. Learn more about how we handle these disputes on our property damage claims page.

How Louis Law Group Helps Security First Insurance Policyholders

Louis Law Group is a Florida property damage law firm that has built its practice around fighting insurance companies that undervalue or deny legitimate claims. We understand how Security First structures its policies, how its adjusters are trained to minimize exposure, and where the most common disputes arise — particularly for homeowners in South Florida communities like Hollywood, where older housing stock and hurricane vulnerability create a constant stream of contested claims.

Policy-Level Review and Coverage Analysis

Security First policies contain endorsements, exclusions, and sublimits that most homeowners have never read closely. We review your complete policy against the denial letter or settlement offer to identify coverage arguments the insurer may be ignoring or misapplying. We look at every endorsement, every exclusion, and every definition — because insurance companies count on policyholders not reading the fine print.

Independent Damage Assessment Coordination

We work with licensed engineers, roofing experts, and public adjusters to produce independent damage assessments that directly rebut the insurer's position. When Security First's adjuster says the roof only needs a patch and our expert documents that the entire truss system is compromised, the insurer's position becomes much harder to maintain.

Appraisal Representation

We can represent you in the appraisal process — selecting a qualified appraiser, preparing supporting documentation, and ensuring the process moves forward without the insurer using procedural technicalities to stall or undercut your claim.

Bad Faith Litigation

When Security First's conduct crosses the line from aggressive claims handling into legally cognizable bad faith, we pursue the full remedies available under Florida Statute 624.155. This includes serving the Civil Remedy Notice, documenting the insurer's failure to cure, and filing suit in circuit court where appropriate. Bad faith claims can result in damages that significantly exceed your original policy limits.

We represent policyholders on a contingency fee basis for most property damage matters — meaning we don't collect a fee unless we recover for you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Security First Insurance Claims in Florida

How long does Security First have to pay my claim under Florida law?

Under Florida Statute 627.70131, Security First must acknowledge your claim within 14 days of notice and either pay, deny, or issue a partial payment with written explanation within 90 days of receiving your proof of loss. If Security First misses these deadlines without justification, that conduct may support a bad faith claim. However, the insurer may also request extensions, which is why tracking every date and communication in writing is critical.

Can I dispute a Security First settlement offer I already accepted?

It depends on the specific language in the settlement release or proof of loss you signed. Some releases explicitly waive all future claims; others are limited to the items specifically enumerated. If you accepted a partial payment but did not sign a broad release, you may still have the right to pursue additional compensation for undocumented or undervalued damage. An attorney can review the documents you signed and advise you on your options.

What is the appraisal process and will it help me get more money?

The appraisal process is an alternative dispute resolution mechanism built into most Florida homeowners policies. It applies specifically when both parties agree a loss is covered but disagree on the dollar amount. Each side selects an independent appraiser; those appraisers choose an umpire; and a majority decision on the amount of loss is binding. Appraisal awards frequently exceed the insurer's initial settlement offer — sometimes significantly. It is generally faster and less expensive than litigation, making it a valuable tool for many policyholders.

Does SB 2A mean I can't recover attorney fees if I sue Security First?

Not exactly. SB 2A restructured — but did not eliminate — attorney fee recovery in insurance disputes. Under the new framework, fee awards are proportional: if the final judgment is substantially closer to your demand than to the insurer's offer, a larger fee award may follow. If the insurer's offer was close to reasonable, fees may be limited or unavailable. This makes the initial demand letter and documentation strategy more important than ever, which is one of the key reasons to involve an attorney before you file your claim or before you accept any settlement.

What if Security First says my damage is excluded because of flooding?

Florida homeowners policies typically cover wind damage but not flood damage. When a hurricane strikes, insurers often attribute as much loss as possible to flooding in order to avoid coverage under the standard HO policy. However, wind-driven rain that enters through a roof breach caused by hurricane-force winds is generally covered as a windstorm loss — not a flood exclusion event. If Security First is using the flood exclusion to deny what is legally a windstorm claim, that is a coverage dispute that an attorney can challenge with engineering evidence and expert testimony about the sequence and cause of damage.

Don't Accept Less Than You're Owed — Contact Louis Law Group Today

A Security First Insurance denial or low settlement offer does not have to be the final word. Florida law gives you powerful tools to fight back — but those tools have deadlines, procedural requirements, and strategic considerations that are difficult to navigate without experienced legal help.

Louis Law Group represents property damage policyholders across Florida. We know how Security First handles claims, where the disputes arise, and how to build the evidence needed to compel a fair resolution — whether through negotiation, appraisal, or litigation.

Do not wait. Claim deadlines under your policy and Florida law can cut off your rights faster than you expect. Contact Louis Law Group today for a free consultation. Tell us what Security First offered, what your independent contractor estimated, and what happened when you pushed back. We'll tell you honestly whether you have a case — and what we can do to help you recover the full value of your loss.

Related Articles

• Property Damage Claims