Industry Insight: Federal Reinsurance Backstop Proposed to Stabilize Home Insurance

Federal Reinsurance Backstop: What "US Re" Could Mean for Florida

The Brookings Institution's Hamilton Project has released a policy proposal for a federal reinsurance backstop called "US Re" — a program designed to leverage federal borrowing power to stabilize the private home insurance market in catastrophe-prone states like Florida.

The Problem US Re Aims to Solve

Florida's property insurance market has been in crisis for years. Homeowners face skyrocketing premiums, carrier insolvencies, and a shrinking pool of willing insurers. The root cause is reinsurance — the insurance that insurance companies buy to protect themselves against catastrophic losses.

After major hurricanes, reinsurance costs spike dramatically. Carriers pass those costs to policyholders through higher premiums, or exit the market entirely. This cycle has left Florida with:

• Average homeowner premiums among the highest in the nation
• Over a dozen carrier insolvencies since 2020
• Citizens Property Insurance — the state's insurer of last resort — holding the largest market share in the state
• Reduced coverage options, especially in coastal and hurricane-prone areas

How US Re Would Work

The proposed federal backstop would function similarly to the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act (TRIA), which was created after 9/11 to stabilize the commercial insurance market. Key features include:

• Federal reinsurance layer — The government would provide reinsurance coverage above a defined threshold, reducing the cost of private reinsurance for carriers.
• Premium reduction mechanism — Lower reinsurance costs should translate to lower premiums for homeowners.
• Risk-based pricing — Participating carriers would still be required to price risk accurately, preventing moral hazard.
• Mitigation incentives — The program would incentivize states and homeowners to invest in wind mitigation, building code enforcement, and disaster preparedness.

What This Means for Florida PAs and Policyholders

If enacted, a federal reinsurance backstop could significantly reshape Florida's property insurance landscape:

More Carriers, More Competition: Lower reinsurance costs could encourage carriers that have exited Florida to re-enter the market, giving policyholders more options and potentially driving down premiums.

Citizens Depopulation: A more stable private market would accelerate the depopulation of Citizens Property Insurance, moving policyholders into private coverage with potentially better terms.

Claims Handling Impact: With improved financial stability, carriers may be less likely to aggressively deny or underpay claims as a cost-containment measure — a practice that has been widespread in Florida's stressed market.

For Public Adjusters: A healthier insurance market means more carriers to work with, but also potentially fewer disputes arising from carrier financial distress. PAs should monitor this proposal as it moves through the legislative process.

Current Status

The US Re proposal is currently in the policy discussion phase. It would require Congressional action to implement, and faces potential opposition from carriers that benefit from the current market structure and from fiscal conservatives concerned about federal exposure to catastrophe risk.

Practical Takeaways

• This is a long-term development — Don't expect immediate changes. Federal legislation typically takes years to move from proposal to implementation.
• Current claims remain unaffected — Policyholders and PAs dealing with current carrier issues should continue pursuing their claims aggressively under existing law.
• Monitor legislative progress — Track this proposal through the Hamilton Project and Congressional committee hearings.
• Continue documenting carrier misconduct — Regardless of future market reforms, bad faith and claims handling violations remain actionable under current Florida law.

How Louis Law Group Can Help

While federal reinsurance reform may eventually improve Florida's insurance market, policyholders dealing with denied claims, underpayments, and carrier bad faith today need legal representation now. Louis Law Group handles property damage litigation across Florida on a contingency basis — you pay nothing unless we win.

If your carrier has denied, delayed, or underpaid a property claim, contact us for a free case review at (833) 657-4812 or submit a policy for review through our website.

---

Source: Insurance Journal — Is a Federal Reinsurance Backstop the Answer to Home Insurance Challenges?