Public Adjuster vs Lawyer in Miami Insurance Claims

When facing an insurance claim dispute in Miami, Florida, property owners often wonder whether they should hire a public adjuster or an attorney. Both professionals can assist with insurance claims, but they serve fundamentally different roles with distinct advantages and limitations. Understanding these differences is critical to protecting your rights and maximizing your insurance recovery.

What Public Adjusters Do in Florida

A public adjuster is a licensed professional who works on behalf of policyholders to assess property damage and negotiate claim settlements with insurance companies. In Florida, public adjusters must be licensed by the Department of Financial Services and are regulated under Florida Statutes Chapter 626.

Public adjusters typically handle the following responsibilities:

• Documenting and estimating property damage
• Preparing detailed inventories of damaged or destroyed items
• Reviewing insurance policies to identify covered losses
• Submitting claims documentation to insurance carriers
• Negotiating settlement amounts with insurance adjusters

In Miami-Dade and Broward counties, public adjusters commonly handle claims involving hurricane damage, water intrusion, roof damage, and fire losses. They charge fees typically ranging from 10% to 20% of the final settlement amount, though Florida law caps public adjuster fees at 20% for most claims and 10% for claims related to declared states of emergency during the first year.

Important limitation: Public adjusters cannot provide legal advice, represent you in court, or file lawsuits against insurance companies. They are not authorized to practice law under Florida Statutes Section 454.23.

What Insurance Attorneys Can Do

An attorney licensed to practice law in Florida can provide comprehensive legal representation throughout the insurance claim process and beyond. Insurance lawyers handle the full spectrum of claim-related issues, including litigation when necessary.

Florida insurance attorneys provide services including:

• Legal interpretation of insurance policy language and coverage provisions
• Analysis of policy exclusions and limitations
• Representation in appraisal proceedings under Florida law
• Filing lawsuits for breach of contract or bad faith
• Conducting discovery and depositions
• Representing clients in mediation, arbitration, and trial
• Pursuing bad faith claims under Florida Statutes Section 624.155
• Recovering attorney's fees when applicable under Florida law

Florida maintains specific statutes that often allow policyholders to recover attorney's fees from insurance companies when they prevail in litigation. This fee-shifting provision under Florida Statutes Section 627.428 means that in many cases, the insurance company must pay your attorney's fees if you win your case, making legal representation more accessible.

Key Differences That Matter in Miami Claims

The distinction between public adjusters and attorneys becomes particularly significant when insurance companies deny claims, offer unreasonably low settlements, or engage in bad faith practices—scenarios that occur frequently in South Florida's complex insurance market.

Scope of representation: Public adjusters negotiate claim amounts but cannot challenge wrongful denials through legal channels. Attorneys can file lawsuits, subpoena documents, depose insurance company employees, and compel insurance companies to comply with Florida law.

Bad faith claims: When insurance companies unreasonably deny valid claims or fail to properly investigate losses, they may be liable for bad faith damages under Florida law. Only attorneys can pursue these claims, which may result in compensation beyond the policy limits, including consequential damages and attorney's fees.

Complex coverage disputes: Miami properties often involve complicated coverage issues—multiple policies, assignment of benefits agreements, building code upgrades, ordinance or law coverage, and business interruption claims. Attorneys can interpret complex policy language and argue legal precedents that public adjusters cannot address.

Timeline considerations: Florida law imposes strict deadlines for filing insurance lawsuits. For property insurance claims, policyholders typically have five years from the date of loss to file suit under Florida's statute of limitations for written contracts. However, waiting too long to consult an attorney can jeopardize your ability to recover.

Can You Use Both Professionals?

Many Miami policyholders benefit from engaging both a public adjuster and an attorney, particularly for large or complex claims. This collaborative approach can be highly effective when roles are properly coordinated.

A public adjuster can document damage thoroughly and prepare detailed claim estimates while an attorney ensures your legal rights are protected and deadlines are met. If the insurance company denies the claim or disputes coverage, the attorney can immediately transition to litigation using the documentation the public adjuster has compiled.

However, coordination is essential. Some public adjusters work regularly with specific law firms, creating efficient teams familiar with Florida's insurance landscape. When considering this approach, ensure both professionals communicate effectively and understand their respective roles.

Making the Right Choice for Your Miami Claim

Several factors should guide your decision between hiring a public adjuster, an attorney, or both:

Claim complexity: Straightforward property damage claims with cooperative insurance companies may be well-served by public adjusters alone. Claims involving coverage disputes, partial denials, or insurance company bad faith require attorney involvement.

Insurance company response: If your insurance company has denied your claim, offered an unreasonably low settlement, delayed without justification, or failed to properly investigate your loss, consult an attorney immediately. These are potential indicators of bad faith that public adjusters cannot adequately address.

Claim size: For significant losses involving substantial property damage or business interruption, attorney representation helps ensure you receive full compensation and that complex policy provisions are properly applied.

Time sensitivity: If you're approaching deadlines for filing suit or responding to insurance company actions, attorney involvement is essential. Public adjusters cannot protect you from missing critical legal deadlines.

Miami's unique insurance environment—marked by hurricane exposure, assignment of benefits disputes, and aggressive insurance company claim handling—often necessitates legal expertise. While public adjusters serve valuable functions in documenting and presenting claims, they cannot substitute for legal counsel when your rights are at stake.

Need Help? If you have questions about your case, call or text 833-657-4812 for a free consultation with an experienced attorney.

Related Articles

• Insurance Bad Faith in Naples, Florida
• Insurance Denied Water Damage Claim in Florida
• What To Do When Insurance Company Denies Water Damage Cla...