Public Adjuster vs Lawyer: Jacksonville Claims

When a storm damages your Jacksonville home or a pipe bursts and soaks your floors, two professionals will likely compete for your attention: public adjusters and attorneys. Both claim to maximize your insurance settlement, but they operate under fundamentally different legal frameworks, carry different costs, and deliver different results depending on your situation. Understanding the distinction before you sign any contract can mean the difference between a fair payout and leaving thousands of dollars on the table.

What a Public Adjuster Does in Florida

A public adjuster is a licensed insurance professional—not a lawyer—who works on behalf of policyholders to document, calculate, and negotiate property damage claims. In Florida, public adjusters are regulated by the Department of Financial Services under Chapter 626 of the Florida Statutes. They must hold a 3-20 or 3-21 license and are prohibited from providing legal advice or representing you in litigation.

Public adjusters typically earn between 10% and 20% of your settlement. Florida law caps that fee at 20% for non-catastrophe claims and 10% during a declared state of emergency for the first year. Their value is primarily in:

• Conducting detailed damage inspections and preparing comprehensive estimates
• Interpreting policy language to identify covered losses you may have missed
• Communicating with the insurance company's adjuster on your behalf
• Negotiating higher settlements before any legal dispute arises

For straightforward property damage claims where liability is not in dispute and the only fight is over the dollar amount, a skilled public adjuster can be effective. They know construction costs, understand Xactimate pricing software, and speak the same technical language as insurance company adjusters.

What an Insurance Attorney Offers

An insurance attorney can do everything a public adjuster does—and significantly more. In Florida, attorneys handling first-party property insurance claims are governed by the Florida Rules of Professional Conduct and operate under strict ethical obligations to their clients. A licensed attorney can:

• File a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) against your insurer, which is a prerequisite to a bad faith claim under Florida Statute § 624.155
• Pursue litigation in Florida circuit or county court if your claim is wrongfully denied or underpaid
• Conduct formal discovery, including depositions of insurance company employees
• Invoke appraisal clauses and participate in binding appraisal proceedings
• File suit for attorney's fees under Florida's fee-shifting statutes
• Pursue bad faith damages that can exceed your original policy limits

Many Jacksonville insurance attorneys handle property claims on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless they recover money for you. Following Florida's 2023 legislative changes to fee provisions, the contingency arrangement has become the dominant model. This aligns your attorney's interests directly with yours—they only get paid when you do.

Jacksonville-Specific Considerations

Jacksonville presents unique insurance challenges that influence this decision. Duval County sits in a high-wind zone and faces significant hurricane and tropical storm exposure. Properties near the St. Johns River or coastal areas also carry elevated flood and water intrusion risk. Insurance carriers operating in Northeast Florida have become increasingly aggressive in applying policy exclusions, depreciating actual cash value claims, and invoking appraisal to cap their exposure.

Florida's insurance market has undergone dramatic restructuring since 2022. Several insurers have exited the state entirely, and those that remain are scrutinizing claims more aggressively than ever. In this environment, Jacksonville homeowners dealing with disputed or complex claims—particularly those involving wind versus water causation disputes, mold, or contractor supplement disagreements—frequently need legal muscle that a public adjuster simply cannot provide.

Additionally, Florida Statute § 627.70152, which took effect in 2021, requires policyholders to submit a pre-suit notice before filing litigation against their insurer. An attorney understands exactly how to draft and file this notice correctly, preserving your rights. A public adjuster cannot file this document or advise you on its legal implications.

When to Choose One Over the Other

The right choice depends heavily on where your claim stands and how your insurance company is behaving.

Consider a public adjuster when:

• Your claim has been accepted but you believe the settlement offer is too low
• The damage is purely property-based with no coverage dispute
• Your insurer is communicating in good faith but underestimating repair costs
• You need help documenting a large or complex loss before submitting your claim

Consult an attorney immediately when:

• Your claim has been denied in whole or in part
• Your insurer is alleging fraud, misrepresentation, or policy violations
• You have received a reservation of rights letter
• The insurance company is significantly delaying payment beyond the deadlines set in Florida Statute § 627.70131
• You suspect bad faith handling, including lowball offers, ignored communications, or unreasonable documentation demands
• Litigation appears likely or has been threatened by either side

One important caution: some public adjusters operate under assignment of benefits agreements or have informal relationships with contractors that may not serve your interests. Always read any contract carefully before signing. An attorney can review any public adjuster agreement before you commit.

Using Both Professionals Together

In many Jacksonville cases, the most effective strategy involves coordination between a public adjuster and an attorney. A public adjuster can handle the technical damage documentation and initial negotiation, while an attorney monitors the claim for signs of bad faith and stands ready to file suit if the insurer refuses to make a fair offer. Some insurance law firms bring public adjusters in-house or maintain referral relationships for exactly this reason.

If your claim has already reached a breakdown point—denial, lowball offer, prolonged delay—going directly to an attorney makes the most sense. The attorney can retain a public adjuster or independent estimator as a consulting expert within the scope of representation, preserving the attorney-client privilege over that work product.

Time matters in Florida insurance disputes. The statute of limitations for first-party property claims under Florida law is generally five years from the date of loss for breach of contract, but shorter deadlines may apply depending on your specific policy language. Waiting too long to involve an attorney can eliminate legal remedies that would otherwise be available to you.

Jacksonville policyholders should not feel pressured into choosing the first professional who contacts them after a loss. Post-disaster solicitation by both public adjusters and contractors is common and sometimes aggressive. Take time to verify credentials, understand the fee structure, and get a second opinion before signing anything.

Need Help? If you have questions about your case, call or text 833-657-4812 for a free consultation with an experienced attorney.

Related Articles

• Documenting Property Damage in Florida Insurance Claims
• Florida SSDI Disability Hearings: What to Expect
• West Palm Beach Mold Damage Insurance Claims