Case Law Update: Steadfast Insurance Co. v. Grande Isle Towers — Florida Federal Court Allows Insurer's Declaratory Suit Over $26.98M Hurricane Ian Claim Demand

Quick Answer

On Nov. 5, 2026, the M.D. Fla. denied a Rule 12(b)(1) motion to dismiss in Steadfast Insurance Co. v. Grande Isle Towers, No. 2:25-cv-00775, over a $26.98M Hurricane Ian demand.

Submit a Policy or Denial Letter for Review Free review by our property damage attorneys — response within 24 hours.Submit for Review →Ask A Lawyer Ask us anything about your claim — we're online now.Ask Us a Question →Pierre A. Louis, Esq.
Pierre A. Louis, Esq.Louis Law Group

11/12/2026 | 1 min read

On November 5, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida (Fort Myers Division) denied a condominium association’s Rule 12(b)(1) motion to dismiss in Steadfast Insurance Company v. Grande Isle Towers I & II Condominium Association, Inc., Case No. 2:25-cv-00775-SPC-NPM (captioned Case No.: 2:25-cv-775-SPC-NPM; Doc. 110). Steadfast filed the declaratory judgment action on August 26, 2025, seeking declarations of no coverage for disputed portions of Grande Isle’s $41,226,920.40 Hurricane Ian claim after Steadfast paid $17,573,452.54 and the association demanded an additional $26,981,347.00, while Grande Isle counterclaimed for breach of contract and reformation. With the 6-page Opinion and Order rejecting the jurisdictional challenge, Steadfast’s eight declaratory counts and Grande Isle’s counterclaims remain pending.

Background Alleged in the Pleadings

Because Grande Isle brought a facial challenge to subject-matter jurisdiction on the pleadings, the court summarized Steadfast’s complaint (Doc. 1) without deciding coverage merits. According to the Order, Steadfast insured Grande Isle (“Grande Isle”) during Hurricane Ian. Grande Isle submitted a claim for loss of $41,226,920.40 (Doc. 1 ¶ 7), and Steadfast paid $17,573,452.54 (Doc. 1 ¶ 13). Grande Isle demands an additional $26,981,347.00, including approximately $14,861,735.84 for mitigation contractor StopLoss Specialists Inc. (“StopLoss”) and $8,290,909.11 for building damage (Doc. 1 ¶¶ 10–12).

Steadfast sued under the Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2201 (Doc. 1 at 11–17), asserting eight counts seeking a declaratory judgment that the policy provides no coverage:

  • Count I: “For Interest and Legal Fees Arising Under Grande Isle’s Contract with StopLoss”;
  • Count II: for equipment, labor, and materials expended by Grande Isle’s contractor “to Maintain Atmospheric Humidity”;
  • Count III: “For Damage Due to Wear and Tear, and Faulty, Inadequate or Defective Workmanship, Repairs, Construction, Renovation or Maintenance”;
  • Count IV: “To Prevent the Formation or Proliferation of Mold”;
  • Count V: “To Remediate Damage from Presence of Proliferation of Pollutants”;
  • Count VI: “To Remediate Damage from Bacteria or Viruses”;
  • Count VII: “For Loss or Damage Due to Repeated Leakage or Seepage of Water, or the Presence of Humidity, Moisture or Vapor”; and
  • Count VIII: “For Loss or Damage Due to Wind Driven Rain, or Any Loss That is a Consequence of It.”

In its amended answer (Doc. 28 at 32–35), Grande Isle counterclaimed for Breach of Contract (Count I) and Reformation (Count II), which Steadfast answered (Doc. 33). Grande Isle moved under Rule 12(b)(1) to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction (Doc. 78), and Steadfast responded (Doc. 84).

Why the Court Denied the Rule 12(b)(1) Motion

Under Rule 12(h)(3), “[i]f the court determines at any time that it lacks subject matter jurisdiction, the court must dismiss the action.” Citing McElmurray v. Consol. Gov’t of Augusta-Richmond Cnty., 501 F.3d 1244, 1251 (11th Cir. 2007), the court noted that on a facial attack it accepts the pleading’s allegations as true and examines whether jurisdiction is sufficiently alleged.

Under 28 U.S.C. § 2201, standing requires an “actual controversy.” Quoting Indus. Eng’g & Dev., Inc. v. Static Control Components, Inc., No. 8:12-cv-691-T-24-MAP, 2014 WL 3828430, *1 (M.D. Fla. Aug. 4, 2014), the court observed “[t]his ‘actual controversy’ is the same as a justiciable ‘case or controversy’ under Article III.” Quoting Navellier v. Florida, 672 F. App’x 925, 928 (11th Cir. 2016), a party must show “(1) [it] is likely to suffer a future injury; (2) [it] is likely to suffer the injury at the hands of the [opposing party]; and (3) the relief [it] seeks will likely prevent the injury from occurring.”

Grande Isle argued the complaint alleged only a past injury (Doc. 78), while Steadfast argued the ongoing dispute over insurance proceeds presented a potential future injury (Doc. 84). Relying on Aetna Life Ins. Co. of Hartford, Conn. v. Haworth, 300 U.S. 227, 243–44 (1937), the court quoted Haworth: “the character of the controversy and of the issue to be determined is essentially the same whether it is presented by the insured or by the insurer” and “[i]t is the nature of the controversy, not the method of its presentation or the particular party who presents it, that is determinative.”

Because “Grande Isle is still demanding an additional $26,981,347.00 under the policy,” Steadfast alleged a likely future injury, namely “additional payment under the policy,” at the hands of Grande Isle, which “a declaration that no additional money is owed under the policy” would likely prevent. Concluding Steadfast “sufficiently alleged that a case in controversy exists as to all of its claims,” the court held “dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction is inappropriate” and denied the motion.

What This Means If You Have a Florida Property Insurance Claim

This November 5, 2026 Order is a threshold jurisdictional ruling on the pleadings in one commercial condominium dispute; it does not decide whether Steadfast’s policy defenses apply or whether Grande Isle will prevail on its counterclaims, and it does not bind other courts. Still, it illustrates several practical points:

  • Insurers can file first when supplemental proceeds are disputed. Under Haworth, an ongoing demand for additional payments after partial payment can support Article III standing for an insurer’s declaratory suit.
  • Mitigation contracts and humidity charges draw scrutiny. Counts I and II challenge StopLoss contract interest, legal fees, and humidity-control costs. Policyholders should keep logs, moisture readings, and invoices tying mitigation work to covered storm damage.
  • Exclusions often overlap in hurricane claims. Counts III through VIII raise wear and tear, faulty maintenance, mold, pollutants, bacteria or viruses, water seepage, and wind-driven rain. Preserving pre-loss maintenance records can help address causation disputes.
  • Jurisdictional rulings do not decide coverage. Denying a Rule 12(b)(1) motion only means the declaratory counts proceed alongside the insured’s counterclaims.

Every claim turns on its own policy and facts. If your Florida property claim was denied or underpaid, see our denied insurance claim guide, browse Case Law & Industry Insights, or request a free case evaluation. General information as of November 12, 2026, not legal advice.

Submit a Policy or Denial Letter for Review

Our property damage attorneys will review your case and respond within 24 hours · Free · Confidential

Pierre A. Louis, Esq.

Pierre A. Louis, Esq.

Pierre A. Louis is an attorney and founder of Louis Law Group, specializing in property damage insurance claims and Social Security disability (SSDI/SSI). He has recovered over $200 million for clients against major insurance companies.

Have a policy or denial letter? Get a free attorney review — 24-hour response.Check Your Eligibility →Ask a Question (833) 657-4812

★★★★★ 4.7 · 67 Google Reviews

What Our Clients Say

Real reviews from real clients who fought their insurance companies — and won.

★★★★★

"Citizens denied our roof leak claim, but this firm fought for us and got money for our repairs. We even had funds left over after fixing the roof."

★★★★★

"Pierre and his team are amazing. They truly cater to their clients and help you get the most from your insurance company."

★★★★★

"When my insurance company denied my roof damage claim, Louis Law Group stepped in and fought for me. I'm extremely satisfied with the results they obtained."

★★★★★

"They accomplished exactly what they set out to do and helped me finally receive my insurance check."

★★★★★

"Louis Law Group handled our homeowners insurance dispute and got results much faster than we expected. Excellent service and great communication."

★★★★★

"Very professional attorneys with outstanding attention to detail. They will not stop fighting for their clients."

* Reviews from Google. Results may vary by case.

How it Works

No Win, No Fee

We like to simplify our intake process. From submitting your claim to finalizing your case, our streamlined approach ensures a hassle-free experience. Our legal team is dedicated to making this process as efficient and straightforward as possible.

You can expect transparent communication, prompt updates, and a commitment to achieving the best possible outcome for your case.

Free Case Evaluation

Let's get in touch

We like to simplify our intake process. From submitting your claim to finalizing your case, our streamlined approach ensures a hassle-free experience. Our legal team is dedicated to making this process as efficient and straightforward as possible.

12 S.E. 7th Street, Suite 805, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301