Case Law Update: Shuboney v. Commissioner of Social Security — Florida Federal Court Affirms SSI Denial for Anxiety, Treats Job Coach as Nonmedical Source

Quick Answer

On Oct. 30, 2026, the M.D. Fla. affirmed an SSI denial in Shuboney v. Commissioner, No. 5:26-cv-00085, holding job coach and parent statements need no medical-opinion analysis.

Submit a Policy or Denial Letter for Review Free review by our property damage attorneys — response within 24 hours.Submit for Review →Ask A Lawyer Ask us anything about your claim — we're online now.Ask Us a Question →Pierre A. Louis, Esq.
Pierre A. Louis, Esq.Louis Law Group

11/11/2026 | 1 min read

What happened

On October 30, 2026, the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida (Ocala Division) affirmed the Social Security Administration’s denial of Supplemental Security Income (SSI) in Michael Timothy Shuboney v. Commissioner of Social Security, Case No. 5:26-cv-00085-PRL (captioned No. 5:26-cv-0085-PRL). The claimant argued that the administrative law judge (ALJ) failed to properly weigh his own description of his anxiety and the statements of his mother and his job coach. The court rejected that argument, held that substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s decision, and affirmed under sentence four of 42 U.S.C. § 405(g) in a 9-page Order (Doc. 20).

Background and the ALJ’s decision

According to the Order, Mr. Shuboney protectively filed an SSI application on November 12, 2021, claiming disability due to severe anxiety and diabetes. The agency denied the claim initially and on reconsideration. After a March 7, 2025 hearing at which he and a vocational expert testified, the ALJ found him not disabled on April 25, 2025, and the Appeals Council denied review. He filed his federal suit on February 2, 2026.

He was 32 years old when he applied, with a high school education and past retail work. The ALJ found one severe impairment: anxiety disorder. The residual functional capacity (RFC) allowed work at all exertional levels but limited him to simple tasks and simple instructions, “no public contact,” occasional contact with coworkers and supervisors outside of training periods, occasional changes in routine, and no “specific production rate pace, such as assembly line work or an hourly production quota.” Relying on vocational expert testimony, the ALJ found he could work as a Cleaner, Stores Laborer, Cleaner II, and Icer.

Why the court affirmed

The Order states that “[t]he sole issue raised by Plaintiff on appeal is whether the ALJ failed to properly consider Plaintiff’s allegations and subjective complaints.” The claimant argued that daily activities were a legally deficient reason to discount his statements, that normal findings in a calm clinic setting do not show he can handle a stressful workplace, and that his job coach’s assessment of severe limitations matched his own account. The court found the argument “unavailing” for several reasons:

  • Daily activities were one factor, not the only one. The ALJ noted he could go out alone, ride in a car, use a computer, manage finances, shop in stores, play video games, and attend appointments, and that many of these involved public engagement. The court accepted the government’s framing that these activities were “one piece of the evidence.”
  • Mental status exams were largely normal. The ALJ cited numerous examinations noting normal thought process, good insight and judgment, and good attention and concentration. A consultative psychologist found good judgment, good insight, and an overall “good prognosis” in May 2024.
  • Treatment was conservative and effective. The ALJ found medication and regular mental health care had an overall positive impact, which the court held permissible under Wolfe v. Chater, 86 F.3d 1072, 1078 (11th Cir. 1996).
  • The RFC was more restrictive than the state agency opinions. The ALJ declined to credit state agency consultants who found no severe mental impairment and instead adopted greater limitations.

The job coach and mother statements

The most practical part of the ruling concerns third-party statements. The court held that “neither the job coach nor the parent was a medical source,” explaining that “[t]o qualify as a medical source, the source generally must be a licensed healthcare worker,” citing 20 C.F.R. § 416.902(i), and that both were nonmedical sources under § 416.902(j). Because of that, “[t]he ALJ was not required to consider evidence from non-medical sources for persuasiveness under 20 C.F.R. § 416.920c.” The court noted the ALJ did consider those statements; it simply did not have to run them through the supportability-and-consistency analysis that applies to medical opinions.

What this means if you have an SSI or SSDI claim based on anxiety

This is a single district-court order applying a deferential standard of review to one record, and outcomes in other cases depend on their own facts. Still, the ruling highlights several recurring issues:

  • Lay statements help, but they are not medical opinions. Statements from family members, job coaches, and employers can describe how symptoms affect daily life, but under the post-2017 rules an ALJ does not have to evaluate them the way it evaluates a doctor’s or psychologist’s opinion. Where possible, a treating psychiatrist or psychologist should address the same workplace limitations in vocational terms.
  • Normal exam notes carry weight. If clinic visits show calm, organized presentation but symptoms flare under real-world stress, that difference generally needs to be documented by the treating provider, not only argued on appeal.
  • Daily-activity questionnaires matter. Answers about shopping, driving, or using a computer may be read as evidence of functioning. Describing how often, for how long, and with what help or difficulty can give a fuller picture.
  • Vague opinions can be discounted. The ALJ found one consultative opinion only partially persuasive because it did not describe in vocational terms what the claimant could do.

A federal lawsuit challenging a final Social Security decision generally must be filed within 60 days after the mailing of the Appeals Council’s notice under 42 U.S.C. § 405(g); the agency presumes the notice is received five days after its date under 20 C.F.R. § 422.210(c). For an overview of the process, see our Social Security disability guide. More rulings are collected on our Case Law & Industry Insights page.

If your disability claim was denied, Louis Law Group offers a free case evaluation.

Source: Order, Doc. 20, Shuboney v. Commissioner of Social Security, Case No. 5:26-cv-00085-PRL (M.D. Fla. Oct. 30, 2026). This article summarizes a court ruling for general information and is not legal advice. Last updated November 11, 2026.

Submit a Policy or Denial Letter for Review

Our property damage attorneys will review your case and respond within 24 hours · Free · Confidential

Pierre A. Louis, Esq.

Pierre A. Louis, Esq.

Pierre A. Louis is an attorney and founder of Louis Law Group, specializing in property damage insurance claims and Social Security disability (SSDI/SSI). He has recovered over $200 million for clients against major insurance companies.

Have a policy or denial letter? Get a free attorney review — 24-hour response.Check Your Eligibility →Ask a Question (833) 657-4812

★★★★★ 4.7 · 67 Google Reviews

What Our Clients Say

Real reviews from real clients who fought their insurance companies — and won.

★★★★★

"Citizens denied our roof leak claim, but this firm fought for us and got money for our repairs. We even had funds left over after fixing the roof."

★★★★★

"Pierre and his team are amazing. They truly cater to their clients and help you get the most from your insurance company."

★★★★★

"When my insurance company denied my roof damage claim, Louis Law Group stepped in and fought for me. I'm extremely satisfied with the results they obtained."

★★★★★

"They accomplished exactly what they set out to do and helped me finally receive my insurance check."

★★★★★

"Louis Law Group handled our homeowners insurance dispute and got results much faster than we expected. Excellent service and great communication."

★★★★★

"Very professional attorneys with outstanding attention to detail. They will not stop fighting for their clients."

* Reviews from Google. Results may vary by case.

How it Works

No Win, No Fee

We like to simplify our intake process. From submitting your claim to finalizing your case, our streamlined approach ensures a hassle-free experience. Our legal team is dedicated to making this process as efficient and straightforward as possible.

You can expect transparent communication, prompt updates, and a commitment to achieving the best possible outcome for your case.

Free Case Evaluation

Let's get in touch

We like to simplify our intake process. From submitting your claim to finalizing your case, our streamlined approach ensures a hassle-free experience. Our legal team is dedicated to making this process as efficient and straightforward as possible.

12 S.E. 7th Street, Suite 805, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301